Feedback from Reviewers
The Jewish Eye
described TRIUMPH OVER TYRANNY as "a moving and detailed account of the
quest by Soviet Jews to leave the Soviet Union..."
See the full review at
http://www.thejewisheye.com/ps_triumph.html
Rabbi Yechiel Eckstein, President and Founder of the International
Fellowship of Christians and Jews, issued the following message on the
fellowship's website,
www.ifcj.org on April
17, 2009:
Remembering A Modern-Day Exodus
April 17, 2009
Dear Friend of Israel,
The sacred Jewish holiday of Passover is one of the pivotal
festivals of the Jewish year, during which we remember our passage from
bondage into freedom in biblical times.
As I reflect on the story of the Israelites' deliverance from
bondage in Egypt, I am always reminded of the fact that the Jewish
people have experienced many "exoduses." Throughout history, Jews have
sought to escape countries where they have lived in oppressive
circumstances to seek freedom in Israel, their biblical and historic
homeland.
Now a new book chronicles one of the greatest of those movements. Triumph
Over Tyranny by Philip Spiegel
is the first complete account of the monumental effort to rescue Jews
living under oppression in the Soviet Union prior to the fall of
Communism.
What was life in the Soviet Union like for these exiles? In the
foreward to Triumph
Over Tyranny
Natan Sharansky, a Russian Jew and well-known dissident who spent many
years in prison for challenging his country’s oppressive policies,
tells of his experience:
Growing up in Communist Russia, the narrative of the Jewish
people was almost completely unknown to me. This was not by accident:
The Communist regime had declared a decades-long war against Jewish
identity in all its forms. There were mass executions of Jewish
intellectuals and community leaders. Our synagogues and schools were
shut down. Any public expression of Jewish identification was met with
swift and savage punishment; any chance of reconnecting with our Jewish
brothers and sisters beyond the Iron Curtain seemed as likely as the
parting of the Red Sea.
Indeed, few could have predicted the events that would eventually
lead to the doors of freedom opening for Soviet Jews events recounted
so powerfully in Triumph
Over Tyranny by Philip Spiegel
.
News of Israel's amazing victory in the 1967 Six Day War eventually
penetrated the Iron Curtain and emboldened ever-growing numbers of Jews
to speak out against oppression. In turn, Jews worldwide responded by
raising money and staging protests demanding freedom for these people
who had suffered so greatly for so long. The resulting movement played
a part in toppling the evil Communist regime, which paved the way for
Soviet Jews, who had for so long dreamed of coming to Israel, to
finally reach the Promised Land.
Spiegel also readily acknowledges in his book that Christians,
working through The Fellowship's On Wings of Eagles
program, played a key part in the "exodus" of Jews from the Soviet
Union that followed the fall of Communism. Though its mission has
expanded to reach out to oppressed Jewish populations throughout the
world, Wings was initially launched to bring these oppressed people to
freedom in Israel. I am proud to say that the response by our donors to
this initiative was overwhelming.
I strongly urge you to read Spiegel’s book, Triumph
Over Tyranny
.
I think you'll find it a sobering account of the ravages of
anti-Semitism, as well as an uplifting story of God's favor toward His
people and the good that can be accomplished when ordinary people stand
up to confront evil and help the oppressed.
And please consider making a
generous gift today to On Wings of Eagles..
Throughout the world in the former Soviet Union, South America,
Ethiopia, India, and elsewhere there are still Jewish populations
living in poverty and with the daily threat of anti-Semitic
persecution. In these critical times, the work of Wings is as important
as it was 20 years ago.
With prayers for shalom, peace,
Rabbi Yechiel Eckstein
President
The following reviews are posted on www.amazon.com:
|
2 of 2 people found the
following review helpful:
Excellent
history of the Soviet Jewry movement, January 26, 2009
As an individual closely involved in the Soviet Jewry movement from
1964 to the opening of the USSR's iron gates in the 1990s, I found
"Triumph Over Tyranny" the best overall history so far published. It's
wide-ranging, extremely well-documented and touches on many of the
"refuseniks" and Prisoners of Conscience denied emigration by the
Kremlin. It also gives a very good feel of the grassroots nature of the
American movement to free Soviet Jews; that movement gave Congress and
the White House through successive administrations the political will
to pressure Moscow to free its Jews. The Soviet Jewry movement is a
prime case study proving that determined people, with the assistance of
foreign support, can win their liberation even against a mighty power.
|
| |
1 of 1 people found the
following review helpful:
Highly
Recommended, March 24, 2009
As a person deeply involved on behalf of Soviet Jewry in the l980s, it
was a pleasure for me to read this excellent book. The author has
provided information with which i had no personal knowledge. Many of
the individuals are personally known to me, and it is so very important
that this book records their history. For those looking for a
well-written survey history, this is definitely the book for you ! My
thanks to the author for a great read. Donna |
From Booklist, the magazine of the American Library Association:
Spiegel recounts many of the clandestine activities of the Chabad
movement to keep Judaism alive in the Soviet Union during the regimes
of Joseph Stalin and Nikita Khrushchev. Spiegel writes of the Israeli
government’s secret missions to contact and aid Soviet Jews in their
efforts to immigrate to Israel. Citing recently translated KGB
documents, the book describes how leaders in the Kremlin rationalized
their cruel and oppressive actions. Part 1 relates the efforts to save
the “Jews of silence” from 1920 to 1967. Part 2 tells of the Soviet
Jewish resistance and renaissance from 1967 to 1990. Part 3 deals with
the so-called human rights connection (1968–1986). Part 4 describes
support groups in the Free World (1967–2007). Part 5 concerns American
legislative and diplomatic support (1972–2007), and part 6 covers
post-Soviet campaigns (1991–2007). The book is a compelling read. —
George Cohen
.........................................................................
From a retired Stanford University librarian:
Dear Phil
After listening to
the inspiring talk that you gave at the Newton Public library, I just
had to buy a copy of Triumph Over Tyranny. Reading
the book more than lived up to your presentation. Each
chapter told more amazing stories. It is a treasure
of a book. In
these times when the news media and writers are so often focused on the
evil people do to one another, your refreshing book concentrates on the
power of good. What a great lesson: that righteous
individuals with determination, effort, and vision can vanquish a great
evil. I love your story, because you have created a
blueprint that spells out how single people coming together can repair
the world. How we need this if humanity is to
survive!
Thank you for writing it.
Sally Wieder
.........................................................................
From the former chairperson of the Documentation Committee of the South
Florida Conference on Soviet Jewry:
The Soviet Jewry movement of the late
20th century was a modern day miracle. And Phil Spiegel's account of
the phenomenon is most complete and enjoyable. Triumph Over Tyranny is
an exciting and uplifting read. In describing the heroic campaign that
saved 2 million Soviet Jews, he inspires us all to further our social
action activities in all fields of endeavor.
Margery Sanford
.........................................................................
The following endorsements appear on the book’s jacket:
"The best reason to record and remember how Soviet Jews were
saved is to be prepared to act again when the need arises. If we are
ever to live in a civilized world, what was accomplished for the Soviet
Jews must become the rule rather than the exception. We must not only
preach the doctrine of human rights, we must learn how actually to be
our brother's keeper."
- George P. Shultz, 60th U.S. Secretary of State (addressing
the American Jewish Historical Society in 2007)
“…efforts being done today to preserve the memory, including this
important book by Philip Spiegel, are so crucial to make sure that the
story of the struggle and its lessons are kept alive.
- Natan Sharansky, former Prisoner of Zion and Israeli Cabinet
Minister; Chairman of the Adelson Institute for Strategic Studies
“Philip Spiegel has written a fascinating account of one of the
great human rights struggles of our time, the struggle of the Jews of
the Soviet Union to be able to live in a land where being Jewish would
not be a burden or a crime.”
- Sir Martin Gilbert, Author of seventy-two books, Winston
Churchill's official biographer, and one of Britain's leading historians
"Spiegel illuminates a "tipping point" for global Jewish
peoplehood where pro-activity, idealism and creative activism converge.”
- Wayne Firestone, President, Hillel: The Foundation for
Jewish Campus Life
“A well researched book and a powerful story that should remind
us that freedom is not a given, and that the thirst for it can defeat
the strongest regimes in the darkest of times.”
- Wyatt Andrews, CBS News correspondent
“Philip Spiegel brings to life an important chapter of modern
Jewish history that is too often forgotten: The extraordinary efforts
of Jews in the West to save the Jews of the Soviet Union from
extinction. This detailed account of Jewish mobilization in Europe,
Canada, and the United States makes fascinating and inspiring reading.”
- Prof. Susannah Heschel, Eli Black Professor of Jewish
Studies, Dartmouth College
The following excerpts are from comments by individuals who
reviewed drafts of chapters in which they were personally involved.
“I am deeply impressed and overwhelmed reading the overview and
the Chapter 11 of your book. The job that you fulfilled was absolutely
incredible!”
- Mark Berenfeld, Former refusenik seminar leader
“I am enthralled by your research and your detailed presentation.
I thank you for the efforts you have expanded to bring this subject to
the public. Please let me know when the book is officially published
and how I can purchase a few copies.”
- Victor Borden, M.D., Medical Mobilization for
Soviet Jews
“Excellent! I'm so glad someone is bringing all the parts
together.”
- Jack Cohen, Founder, Committee of Concerned
Scientists
“I read the chapter you sent and was very impressed with the
scope of your research and accuracy of your account of the events
covered. I was privileged to play a role in this historic movement and
am honored to be included and quoted in your book. I look forward to
the issuance of the book so that I can buy some copies for my
grandchildren so they can see how a small group of ordinary people can
spawn and foster a major and successful worldwide movement to help free
oppressed people. Thanks for doing the important work of chronicling
this unprecedented effort.”
- William Cohen, Founder, Center for Human Rights Advocacy
“I appreciate very much your kindness in sending to me the
excellent chapter in your book on Soviet Jewry.”
- Robert F. Drinan, S. J., now deceased, former Member of
Congress
“I just finished it and I am speechless! What a wonderful job you
have done and how much effort was spent on it. It brought back so many
memories and even gave me so much that I had forgotten or never knew.
This is a book that was sorely needed and I salute you for having done
it. Thank you, thank you, thank you! In the years or centuries to come,
when the Haggadah of the 2nd Exodus will be written and recited, your
book will be a major resource and inspiration.”
- Si Frumkin, Founder, Southern California Council for Soviet
Jews
“Thank you very much for sharing with me your well written
Chapter 24. George Shultz and Richard Schifter deserve all the credit
we can give them. They made a great team together and both worked
independently as well in advancing the cause of human dignity.”
- Ambassador Max Kampelman
“You obviously have done a huge amount of work researching and
preparing this manuscript and you have the most wonderful easy style.
The book is going to be a great read. I cannot wait to get a copy.”
- Helene Kenvin, Founder, The Caucasus Network
“This is an impressive work. You do a great job capturing the
emotion and determination of the key players.”
- Pnina Levermore, Executive Director, Climate of Trust Council
“I read the chapter right away, and it was engrossing reading! I
think you have done a great service, and I will really look forward to
the appearance of your book.”
- Rabbi Sheldon Lewis, Rabbi Emeritus, Congregation Kol Emeth,
Palo Alto, CA
"Thanks much. It's fascinating!"
- Rabbi Haskel Lookstein, Principal of Ramaz School, New York
“Congratulations - it's a great effort! I'm really proud of your
work - it's so necessary.”
- Kathryn Cameron Porter, President, Leadership Council for
Human Rights
“Kol Hakavod! on a job well done.”
- Moshe Pripstein, Founder, Scientists for Sakharov, Orlov, and
Sharansky
“What a treasure trove!!! The classes went extremely well, in no
small part thanks to your help. The kids learned a LOT, and took it all
to heart. As I've said, most of them are Russian Jewish emigres (though
none are children of Refuseniks), and I think it came as a huge
revelation and surprise to them what their parents and grandparents had
gone through in the former Soviet Union. Several of them began to offer
stories from their parents - which also warmed my heart - it meant that
they were telling their parents about what they'd learned in school
that day, encouraging the parents to share stories with their
offspring. I never could have done it without your book, and I hope
that the book is in print by next spring so I can use it with my class
- maybe even get a classroom set of the books for them to read chapters
from. The wonderful advantage of your book is that is presents the core
material in an engaging way. The other sources I'd used were either too
abbreviated, or so dry and academic that even I had trouble wading
through them.”
- Mimi Real, History teacher, Hebrew Academy of San Francisco
“I can’t wait to read the rest of the book. It’s very exciting!”
- David Selikowitz, Founder, Comité des Quinze, Paris
“Thank you very much for sending me the text. I am impressed with
the result.”
- Rabbi Awraham Soetendorp, Founder, Green Cross International
“Good stuff and a good read!”
- David Waksberg, Former Executive Director, Bay Area Council
for Soviet Jews
“I think the chapter is great. I think you capture the essence of
the UCSJ and its evolution into a vital part of the successful end
result of the movement. That is precious. I am really looking forward
to reading the whole thing. This is an important work.”
- Zev Yaroslavsky, Supervisor, Los Angeles County
“I was very much impressed how accurate and captivating was this
chapter, and I have read a lot of stuff on the topic. I think the
description of the trial was very powerful and emotional. My 20 year
old son really liked it. It was very passionate and moving.”
- Israel Zalmanson, Former Prisoner of Conscience